
Okay, so let me preface this entry by saying that I may sometimes indeed watch "Days of Our Lives" the soap opera. This is probably where this idea in my head about blackmail came from. That being said, let me continue on with my little diddy.
First off, extortion and blackmail are two very different things. Extortion is the demand for money or other valuable consideration coupled with the the threat to do something that
is and should be illegal.
Example 1:Give me X amount of money or I will kidnap your children
or
Example 2: Sleep with me or I will burn down your house
Both are illegal, this is extortion
Blackmail is all together different. Blackmail is the demand for money or other valuable consideration coupled with the threat
that is and should be legal.
Example 1: Give me X amount of your money or I will tell everyone that you take a bath with rubber duckies.
or
Example 2: Sleep with me or I will gossip about your hidden adultrey
Now, taking a bath with rubber duckies is not illegal nor is gossiping in the laws context.
These examples came with great help by Professor Walter Block and maybe the influence of Days of Our Lives (which by the way, the same thing is still going on from when I had to sneak to watch it in the fifth grade).
Blackmail is an enigma. How can two acts that are both legal when paired together be illegal? I overhear a conversation, some juicy gossip, why can't I demand for money to keep it quiet and not tell the neighborhood. Afterall, it was the stupid person who said it in public when it was meant to be private. Not my fault, right? So maybe I'm stuck on this because I would love to overhear a political conversation and demand money, I'm so sick of being poor as a grad. student! So this could be a bit biased to begin with.
And lastly, I'm not saying blackmail is ethical, but I do think it should be lawful! I conclude by saying that the evidence that blackmail should be legal is overwhelming. It consists of two legal acts which are properly legal and the interaction between them should not illicit them illegal.
Anybody have anything on anyone?